Subscriber OnlyLetters

Time to end church celibacy

Unless the church introduces effective reforms very soon, it will be too late to improve matters

Letter of the Day
Letter of the Day

Sir, – The Irish Catholic Synod discussed restoring women to the ordained Diaconate last month. Synod members are sworn to secrecy, so we know nothing of their discussions. However, it is highly unlikely they will effect much change in the attitudes of a church so extraordinarily leaden–footed in introducing the simple reforms needed to counter the large decline in vocations to the priesthood.

Deacons can baptise children and adults and preside at weddings, funerals and burials, but they cannot celebrate Mass, hear confessions or grant absolution.

Deacons cannot replace priests, but they could greatly ease the workload of the rapidly diminishing priestly workforce, helping to tide the church over the current famine in priestly vocations.

The Diaconate, both men and women, was important in the early church but declined greatly by the fifth century when priests took over entirely. In very recent times, the church, motivated by the collapse in vocations to priesthood, revived the diaconate, but this time confined exclusively to men who must take a vow of celibacy.

There is no biblical prescription of mandatory celibacy for any followers of Christ. Priests got married in the early church, and vows of celibacy for priests weren’t introduced for a long time. And priests marry in other Christian churches, including our sister Greek Orthodox Catholic Church.

Vocations to the priesthood have now declined to a trickle in the western church, surely massively influenced by the fact that today’s young people find it extremely difficult to contemplate lifelong celibacy. A simple solution to this supply problem would be to make celibacy optional for the priesthood and the diaconate and to reinstate the female Diaconate.

But I’m mystified as to why the church is so hung up on celibacy anyway. The recent clerical sex scandals were abuses mostly carried out by men who had taken vows of celibacy.

I don’t think introducing optional celibacy would result in huge numbers of young men signing up for the priesthood, but I’m confident enrolment would improve and at least remove the prospect of the church entirely running out of priests in the near future.

Unless the church introduces effective reforms very soon, it will be too late to improve matters. People will grow so disaffected from religion that they just won’t care one way or another about the future of the church. – Yours, etc,

WILLIAM REVILLE,

Emeritus professor,

UCC,

Cork.