Sir, – The Taoiseach and Tánaiste are right to demand that the Christian Brothers account for their handling of abuse.
But their criticism would carry more credibility if Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael had not themselves faced serious accountability questions over the hepatitis C scandals.
Colm Keena’s Irish Times report (“More than 300 former Christian Brothers joined to sex abuse case by new newspaper ad,” November 17th) notes that three former brothers feel unfairly stigmatised; I know of at least one other former brother who believes he has been unfairly stigmatised.
Some brothers abused children in their care, and that must be acknowledged. That does not justify treating every member of the order as guilty, nor does it erase the fact that the order as a whole was used as a source of cheap labour, even before partition. The Taoiseach and Tánaiste should acknowledge that generational exploitation as well – without allowing it to deflect from the abuse. – Yours, etc,
RM Block
DECLAN HAYES,
Raheny,
Dublin 5.
Sir, – Regarding Colm Keena’s report (November 17th): Whatever legal strategy the Christian Brothers choose to employ is their business. If the only answer to that strategy the Irish legal system can put forward is “men with nothing to do with claim being publicly joined as defendants” then the concept of innocent until proven guilty is turned on its head by the High Court.
No one doubts but that the Christian Brothers may have a case to answer, but to include individuals in a public advertisement in a tabloid newspaper who may be completely innocent is beyond comprehension and a slur on innocent individuals and their families. Is this the best that the cream of our legal profession can come up with? – Yours, etc.
NOEL HOWARD,
Kilworth,
Co Cork.












