Restoring biodiversity on the Yangtze river: ‘You have to do some balancing and make some difficult choices’

Home to several rare species and the world’s largest hydroelectric power station, protecting human life and biodiversity on the Yangtze river is a difficult balancing act

Three Gorges Dam in Yichang, China. Photograph: Bloomberg
Three Gorges Dam in Yichang, China. Photograph: Bloomberg

Yang Jin was taking his daily walk along the Yangtze river, close to the Three Gorges Dam, when he spotted something worrying in the water.

The 67 year-old pensioner has cultivated a hobby of photographing the Yangtze finless porpoise, an aquatic mammal endemic to the river which was on the verge of extinction a few years ago.

A finless porpoise was thrashing about in distress on the water’s surface and when Yang looked more closely, he saw that it was entangled in an abandoned fishing net. Although the porpoise lives in the water, it needs to surface for air and this one was in danger of drowning so Yang called the local fishing authorities.

They halted all shipping in the area and sent a team via speedboat to cut through the net and rescue the porpoise. The animal had cut itself struggling to escape from the net but its rescuers decided it was not too serious so they released it into the river.

READ MORE

“I was worried about its injury and whether it would get infected so I visited every day to photograph and monitor it,” Yang says. “Fortunately, I captured the moment it leapt out of the water. Its tail showed scars when it emerged, and I found it was pregnant. Around late April to early May, it successfully gave birth to a calf.”

The number of finless porpoises in the Yangtze river halved from 3,600 in the 1990s to 1,800 in 2006 and by 2012 there were 1,045 left. But the decline stopped around 2017 and in the five years after that, the population grew by 23 per cent.

“The main reason is the fishery ban,” says Wang Ding, a professor at the Institute of Hydrobiology in the Chinese Academy of Sciences and China’s top representative in Unesco’s Man and the Biosphere programme.

China imposed a 10-year ban on commercial fishing in the Yangtze river, its seven main tributaries and two biggest lakes. Private, recreational fishing is allowed but anything on a bigger scale is punishable by law.

“That’s the main measure we have been carrying out to protect the Yangtze river. Also to remove literally every chemical factory at least 1km away from the Yangtze river,” Wang says. “If you are sitting right here on the bank, you have to go and of course, the government will pay you to move. The water quality has been improved quite a lot.

Yang Jin, an amateur photographer of finless porpoises, on a bank of the Yangtze River
Yang Jin, an amateur photographer of finless porpoises, on a bank of the Yangtze River

“The Yangtze finless porpoise sits right on the top of the food chain of the biodiversity. If he’s doing well, it means the biodiversity of the Yangtze river is doing well. If the number is increasing, it means the situation of ecological conditions of the Yangtze river are improving.”

Restoring the Yangtze river’s biodiversity is made more challenging by the impact of the Three Gorges Dam, the world’s biggest hydroelectric power station and one of the most controversial engineering projects ever undertaken.

Built between 1994 and 2012, the dam is 2,335 metres long and 185 metres high, creating a reservoir that stretches for 600km.

The dam’s most important function was to control the flooding that caused huge damage and loss of life along the river, affecting cities like Wuhan and Nanjing, which were home to millions of people. It was also a major new source of cheap, sustainable energy and improved navigation on the river, especially for cargo ships.

The Chinese Academy of Sciences warned in advance about the dam’s likely impact on the environment and the plan met unusually strong resistance in the National People’s Congress. China’s generally compliant legislature approved the dam in 1992 with 1,767 votes in favour but 177 voted against it. There were 664 abstentions and 25 invalid ballots.

The Three Gorges Dam and low water levels along the Yangtze river in Yichang, China. Photograph: Bloomberg
The Three Gorges Dam and low water levels along the Yangtze river in Yichang, China. Photograph: Bloomberg

More than 1.3 million people saw their homes disappear under water and were forced to relocate, often to less fertile places with inadequate compensation. Some 1,300 archaeological sites and ancient villages were submerged, including centuries-old temples.

The dam destroyed forests, wetlands and habitats for endangered species, trapped industrial waste to create water pollution and triggered thousands of landslides along the river. One of the most seriously affected species was the Chinese sturgeon, a critically endangered species found only in the Yangtze river.

“Chinese sturgeon used to go way up the river more than 1,000km from here to spawn. But because of this dam, the Chinese sturgeon can’t go there, to their old spawning area,” Wang says.

Prof Wang Ding, of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, is an expert on the Yangtze finless porpoise
Prof Wang Ding, of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, is an expert on the Yangtze finless porpoise

The Chinese sturgeon found a small spawning area downstream but their numbers have continued to decline, despite increasingly energetic efforts to save the species. At the Yangtze River Rare Fish Breeding Base, thousands of Chinese sturgeon swim in vast circular steel tanks as they wait to be released into the river.

Last year, the breeding base released 200,000 into the Yangtze river and they are planning to increase the annual number to more than a million. Each fish is fitted with a tracking device and at least 70 per cent of those released make the journey downstream into the sea, where they typically spend more than 14 years before coming back to the river to breed for the first time.

In the giant turbine room of the Three Gorges Dam power station, red lights mark the turbines that are currently in operation. In the control room, engineers monitor the inflow and outflow of water, the electricity generated and to which parts of central and eastern China it is distributed on the grid.

“If we want to generate more electricity, we must keep the water high. But if we want to control flooding, we must keep the level low. Now it is at a low level. It’s not good for our electric power, but it’s good for flood control,” says Yang Peng, deputy director of the operations department at the power station.

“We do our best to protect the fish. During the breeding time, we can control the water flow to meet the need of the fish so then fish can breed.”

Martyn Turner Cartoon
Chinese sturgeon and carp in cultivation tanks at the Yangtze River Rare Fish Breeding Base

One problem created by the dam and its reservoir is the spread of algal blooms that form a green scum on the water surface, depleting oxygen in the water and harming aquatic life. The China Three Gorges Corporation, which runs the dam, has invested heavily in mitigation efforts in recent years, under instructions from Beijing, and the water quality is improving.

“We can’t say the water quality in the Yangtze river is getting better because of the dam. The Three Gorges Dam creates some problems because it cut out the mainstream of the river. The water flow is getting slower and slower. So that provides a fundamental basis for this algal bloom and that’s really bad,” Wang says.

“But the Three Gorges Corporation, they are investing quite a lot of money, required, of course, by central government who said you have to take care of this. So they set up wastewater processing stations in every single town along the river. And also some other big measures like not cutting trees, restoring the forest along the bank, and controlling pollution from farming and stuff like that. These are the reasons the water quality is becoming better.

The corporation’s actions reflect a remarkable shift in public attitudes and in government policy towards the environment in recent years. Years before he became the Communist Party’s general secretary and China’s president, Xi Jinping championed the closure of polluting factories as party secretary in Zhejiang province.

China’s president Xi Jinping championed the closure of polluting factories as Communist Party secretary in Zhejiang province. Photograph: Florence Lo-Pool/Getty Images
China’s president Xi Jinping championed the closure of polluting factories as Communist Party secretary in Zhejiang province. Photograph: Florence Lo-Pool/Getty Images

“Lucid waters and lush mountains are invaluable assets,” he wrote in 2005. “Lucid waters and lush mountains can bring invaluable assets but invaluable assets cannot buy lucid waters and lush mountains.”

Since becoming leader in 2012, Xi has embedded the requirement to balance environmental protection with economic development into national policy. This saw the establishment of five national parks in 2021, with plans to designate 49 by 2035 covering 10 per cent of China’s land area.

Among the leading candidates for such a designation is Shennongjia Forestry District, one of China’s most biodiverse areas with dense primeval forests, alpine meadows and karst landscapes. The forest is also home to the golden snub-nosed monkey, one of China’s most endangered primate species.

“When we first established this nature reserve, the population of golden snub-nosed monkeys was only a little over 500. Now, after more than 40 years of protection, there are more than 1,600,” says Yang Jingyuan, head of the reserve’s scientific research institute, as he takes a peanut from his pocket and hands it to a monkey.

“We need to protect its living environment and provide a sufficiently large habitat with adequate food, water, and shelter, so that the golden monkey feels comfortable living here. In this case, its population will grow rapidly. Golden monkeys are very gentle. If you don’t harm them, they will never actively harm you.”

In the core area of the Shennongjia reserve, only those engaged in scientific monitoring can enter. A belt around that allows visitors under restricted conditions and an outer circle is developed with hotels, shops and other businesses.

Golden snub-nosed monkeys in Shennongjia Forest, Hubei province
Golden snub-nosed monkeys in Shennongjia Forest, Hubei province

“Sometimes we have to balance all kinds of requirements. For example for the Three Gorges Dam, flood control is about life. It’s very important because if the river bank is broken, it could cause many people to die. That’s the first most important thing,” Wang says.

“Navigation is another big issue because the river section above the Three Gorges Dam was very narrow and the current was strong. So no big ship could go up all the way to Chongqing. Now it’s much better and also, of course, we have clean energy. So you have to do some balancing and make some difficult choices, right?”