Charlie versus Garret part two: Grotesque! Unbelievable! Bizarre! Unprecedented!

Pat Leahy and Hugh Linehan continue the story of the greatest rivalry in Irish political history

Listen | 47:09
Pat Leahy continues the story of the rivalry between Fine Gael's Garret FitzGerald and Fianna Fáil's Charles Haughey. Illustration: Paul Scott
Pat Leahy continues the story of the rivalry between Fine Gael's Garret FitzGerald and Fianna Fáil's Charles Haughey. Illustration: Paul Scott

The stage is set. Our two protagonists have risen to become leaders of their respective parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, which between them command the support of nearly 90 per cent of the electorate. But neither has yet received a mandate to govern.

Charles Haughey is taoiseach but bedevilled by division in his own party. Garret Fitzgerald is intent on launching a constitutional crusade to liberalise Irish society. But in the wider world, Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan are starting to push back against liberalism and reshape the postwar economic consensus. But Ireland, meanwhile, remains mired in economic stagnation.

Beneath the surface, though, the country is changing. The old conservative order may still see to hold sway but changes are starting to happen. And the grim toll of violence in Northern Ireland continues to cast a pall, culminating in the hunger strikes of 1981 which have a direct impact on the election of that year.

That election will be the first of three within the space of 17 months, spanning a turbulent political period of deals, heaves and scandal, some of it of Haughey’s making, some not. His political obituary is written several times, but each time he survives.

READ MORE

At the end of it all, Fitzgerald emerges at the head of a coalition government with a narrow but adequate majority. But what will he do with it?