Taxing sugary drinks

Sir – The Irish soft drinks industry welcomes Irish Heart's statement in these pages that a sugar-sweetened drinks tax would not, by itself, solve the obesity crisis (September 4th). The Irish Beverage Council joins them in calling for a holistic approach to tackle obesity. We will continue to invest in innovation; reducing sugar content while increasing our no-sugar and low-sugar offerings.

The facts are clear. There is less sugar in soft drinks and fewer children are drinking sugar-sweetened drinks daily. A health impact assessment of the tax, commissioned by the Department of Health, found that adults who do not regularly consume sugar-sweetened drinks are just as likely to be overweight, and more likely to be obese, than regular consumers of sugar-sweetened drinks. The same report also found that evidence linking sugar-sweetened drink consumption with weight gain is not conclusive. In Mexico, France, Denmark and Hungary where similar taxes were introduced, obesity rates have increased.

Pursuing a tax on health grounds is a way of looking tough on obesity, without actually tacking obesity.

The idea that a tax should be introduced simply because a lobby group calls for it, despite a lack of supportive evidence, must be challenged.

READ SOME MORE

There is no conclusive evidence that tax reduces obesity. It is simply not fair to increase the cost of everyone’s weekly shop as a first step, in the hope that a range of future “multifaceted interventions” might make it work. – Yours, etc,

COLM JORDAN,

Director,

Irish Beverage Council,

Baggot Street, Dublin 2.