It is 2021 and, despite some great advances in space exploration, we are no closer to knowing whether men are from Mars and women are from Venus. In fact, the growing consensus is that we are all from Earth, and people are more complex than we usually give them credit for.
But what if there were a way of unlocking some of the hidden trends that exist among men and women, which reveal how they think, see themselves and communicate? And what if it were... emojis?
The biggest mistake straight men make with emojis is the same as their biggest mistake overall: being far too direct or inappropriate
A lot has been written on the so-called war between millennials and Gen Z and the way they use emojis. According to the latest reports, the cry-laughing emoji is passé among zoomers, who prefer to use the skull-and-crossbones symbol to convey that they are literally (but not literally-literally) dead.
But while this generational war is mostly overblown, there are some marked differences in the way men and women use emojis, as evidenced by recent studies analysing millions of messages between them.
For example, when was the last time you saw a woman use the monkey emoji? A favourite among men who have just embarrassed themselves, it may be one of the most divisive out there. One Twitter user jokingly asked: “Should men who use the monkey emoji have rights? Be honest.” It received 18,000 retweets.
Why does the monkey emoji resonate so strongly? And does it really open up a giant door into male psychology? Of course, we shouldn’t generalise. But in some cases, the answer seems to be... yes, it does.
"Men are apologising a lot," says Max Alley, an online dating coach. He works with men and women on their dating profiles and messaging. A big part of his job is going through their chat logs and figuring out where his clients have gone wrong. Often, emojis play a central role.
According to Alley, the biggest mistake straight men make with emojis is the same as their biggest mistake overall: being far too direct or inappropriate. “The eggplant emoji is the stupidest thing any man could ever send to a woman,” says Alley. “But they do.”
He says men will also use the purple-devil emoji in a sexual way with women they barely know. And they’ll try to make it more palatable with the sweating-while-smiling emoji, which shows that they’re being inappropriate and are also aware of the fact they’re being inappropriate.
Amie Leadingham, a dating coach, says she sees this too. “Men get too direct too quickly,” she says. “They assume the person is ready to meet them already, and ready to like them. It can really be a big turnoff for women. The easiest dating secret in the world is make the person feel like they’re the most important person in the room, you know?”
More often than not this causes an awkward situation – and this is where the monkey emoji comes in. “It’s like a face-palm, but it’s meant to soften the blow a little bit,” says Alley. “To be, like, I’m sorry, I messed up, but I’m still cute, though, right?”
Leadingham says she has seen all the different monkey emojis appear frequently in the messages her female clients have received. “Any of the evil monkeys, yeah,” she says. “And then there’s another one where the emoji has pink cheeks and big eyes like they’re embarrassed for you. Oh, wow. Those are not good.”
But is it only the men making people feel uncomfortable? According to both coaches, the answer seems to be yes a lot of the time – but not always. “Honestly, some of my male clients get some weird stuff [from women] too,” Leadingham says. The biggest mistake women make, in her experience, is overexposing themselves in a different way. You could call it “emotional eggplanting”.
Emojis can be a crutch that helps avoid further displays of vulnerability, or at least soften them
In her experience, if a female client does make a mistake, it’s making themselves too vulnerable too soon. “Those are massive red flags, as vulnerability is great but with boundaries, right? They may tell you their life story, and with a lot of drama tied to it. And they’re just dumping it on you.”
In the same way that men then resort to emojis when they realise they have been too forward, Leadingham says that women will also express their embarrassment in the easiest way possible and rely on images to convey how they feel, rather than typing it out. In this way, emojis can be a crutch that helps avoid further displays of vulnerability, or at least soften them. She says common emojis women will use if they feel like they have said too much include the blushing face, the zippered mouth and the sad, downtrodden one – especially if it has led to them being ghosted.
Alley also works with women; he says their big mistake in online dating is leading on a guy who is not worth their time. What this means is that women may not realise just how sexually driven the man they’re talking to is. They may use mildly flirty emojis without realising that the man is interpreting them differently.
This may sound like victim-blaming, but obviously the onus is on men to be better at reading the room, so that mildly flirty emojis can just be that – mildly flirty – and not trigger a barrage of purple aubergines, devil faces or, God forbid, actual real penises.
There are also differences between men and women’s emojis that aren’t quite as awkward. Alley rarely sees straight men using Bitmoji, which allows you to create a cartoon version of yourself, whereas it’s much more popular among women and gay men. And when it comes to his older clients (or “boomers”), he says, emoji use is far more limited to simple smileys, or not used at all.
There are also big differences over repetition and emphasis. “Men will react with the fire emoji pretty frequently to show excitement,” says Alley. “They’ll also use it multiple times, so it’s, like, double or triple fire.” Meanwhile, the women he’s worked with are more likely to use hearts and sparkles to convey positivity and “find images that pair well together to make a statement from it, while men will often amplify the emotion of their statement by just tripling the emoji”.
Male users are significantly more likely to use heart-related emojis than females. This is contrary to psychological literature where males are reported to be less willing to express love in real life
Academic studies have made similar findings. They have found that women use emojis more than men, are more likely to pair sports emojis with baths and showers (versus men who pair them with trophies) and generally have a better knowledge of their different meanings.
In 2018 researchers from Peking University and the University of Michigan were the first to undertake a large-scale analysis of emojis and gender. They looked at 134,000 anonymous Android users from 183 countries, who produced 401 million messages over three months in 58 languages. It was limited due to the fact that it only looked at men and women (rather than being inclusive of all gender identities), but it still threw up some fascinating results.
Chiming with Alley’s observation, the study found that “female users are more likely to use only one emoji or discretely use multiple emojis in a message, [whereas] male users are more likely to consecutively use multiple emojis”. It also discovered that, compared with men, women are more likely to elongate their words to convey heightened emotion and say things such as “coooooooooooooolllll!”.
And then there are emoji users who do not claim a specific gender as their identity. “Past research has been limited to the gender-binary population,” says Sanjaya Wijeratne, a research scientist at the visual-messaging app Holler, who wrote his PhD on emojis.
Given that gender identities exist on a wide spectrum, can emojis help us better understand their various shades? It may be difficult, as the trends between men and women so far seem influenced by traditional notions of gender. In a 2018 study on how people interpret emojis, those who marked their gender as "other" had more differences from the male and female participants than the men and women had between themselves.
While many of the paper’s findings broadly aligned with stereotypical notions of gender, some of them didn’t at all. “We are surprised to find that male users are significantly more likely to use heart-related emojis than females,” the researchers write. “This is contrary to psychological literature where males are reported to be less willing to express love in real life. Such a finding implies that although men reserve to express their love in real life, they are more willing to express love through emojis in textual communication.”
The paper also found that the 10 most popular emojis among women, in order, were the cry-laughing face, love heart, heart-eyes face, kissing face, crying face, smirking face, smiley face, double love hearts, sparkly love heart and happy face.
Meanwhile, the most popular among men were the cry-laughing face, love heart, heart-eyes face, kissing face, crying face, sparkly love heart, smiley face, smirking face, see-no-evil monkey and double love hearts.
The two lists are almost exactly the same, but with one exception: that cheeky, embarrassed, kind of creepy, why-did-you-just-say-that monkey. – Guardian
