A worker who was sacked by Aldi after senior management found out he had been convicted of sexual assault has won €5,000 for unfair dismissal.
A Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) adjudicator concluded there had been a “rush to dismissal” after bosses at the organisation were shown a newspaper report on the man’s court case and accused him of failing to disclose his conviction – even though it later emerged he had told his line manager.
The worker, Muhammad Kashif, a cashier at an unidentified supermarket operated by Aldi Stores Limited (Ireland), had been allowed to keep working for eight weeks after receiving a two-month suspended prison sentence at District Court level, having plead guilty to sexual assault.
Mr Kashif, who was employed by the supermarket group between November 2021 and his termination in February 2023, working around 35 hours a week on average – but was also working two or three shifts a month at a fast-food restaurant, the tribunal heard.
Ireland has been surpassed as ‘the largest open-air lunatic asylum in the world’
Nanci Griffith: From a Distance review – harrowing account of the country music star’s life that ended in isolation and alcoholism
Patrick Freyne: I joined a gym this year. Here’s how working out is working out
‘Show some respect’, Brian Cowen told Gerry Adams in furious Belfast meeting, records show
The company’s barrister, Kiwana Ennis BL, appearing instructed by Vincent and Beatty Solicitors, submitted that Mr Kashif had “pleaded guilty to a charge of sexual assault of a female colleague at a separate employment” in court on December 20th 2022.
The case was covered in the local press, but the report “only came to the attention of higher management” in February 2023, when Mr Kashif was suspended on full pay, Ms Ennis added.
An area manager, Ms A, said in evidence she had been provided with a copy of the newspaper article on February 10th 2023 by another area manager, Mr B, who asked her to “look into it” and “if necessary, start a disciplinary process”.
During a disciplinary process, it was put to Mr Kashif that he had been “convicted of a criminal offence” and “failed to disclose this conviction to your line manager”.
The tribunal heard Mr Kashif confirmed the conviction to company investigators during a disciplinary process – but told them that he had told his line manager about the conviction the day after he was in court. Company meeting minutes noted that the line manager, referred to as Ms Z in the decision, confirmed Mr Kashif’s account, the WRC heard, noting that this was “accepted by the parties”.
Ms A’s evidence was that the store manager, Ms Z, “had not disclosed” Mr Kashif’s conviction.
Aldi’s lawyers submitted that Mr Kashif’s contract of employment provided for summary dismissal for any criminal conviction “other than a minor motoring offence”, and he had admitted the conviction.
.
Mr Kashif’s barrister, Constantine McMahon, instructed by Michael O’Donnell Solicitors, argued there had to be a connection between misconduct outside the workplace and the needs of an employer’s business to justify the “nuclear” option of dismissal.
Adjudicator Patsy Doyle wrote that there had been no regard paid to Mr Kashif’s “unblemished record” or the eight weeks of “uneventful service” after he disclosed the conviction to his bosses.
She found Aldi was “overwhelmed” by seeing the newspaper report at a later stage and “got lost in its anticipation of harm to the business”.
“I have found the rush to dismissal was blighted by the respondent’s fear of anticipatory harm rather than actual harm caused by the print media, where it seems to me that the respondent was not named,” she added.
Ms Doyle concluded that the facts before her were not “conclusive proof of substantial grounds for dismissal” and found that Aldi had “veered outside the band of reasonableness for a reasonable employer”.
She upheld Mr Kashif’s complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977, but found the complainant bore 50 per cent responsibility for his termination. She awarded him €5,000 in compensation, a sum equivalent to two months’ gross wages.
- Sign up for push alerts and have the best news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone
- Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date
- Listen to our Inside Politics podcast for the best political chat and analysis