Solicitor defends Smithwick report as ‘nuanced and fair’

Critique by former gardaí said to display keenness to accept IRA’s version

Court challenge unlikely to overturn tribunal findings

Opinion: There is limited scope to question on the basis an alleged error of fact

Contesting Smithwick key finding

Three former senior gardaí challenge tribunal findings

Key Smithwick Tribunal conclusions not based on facts, says critique from ex-gardaí

Lack of basic crime reconstruction a ‘serious omission’, say former gardaí

Former officers say a reconstruction would have demonstrated the sheer logistical improbability of such a complex crime operation being based on information supplied at a moment’s notice

The authors: Career gardaí who served at highest levels

Three retired gardaí publish comprehensive challenge of Smithwith Tribunal findings