The Irish Times view on Ireland’s changing suburbs: old mistakes in new places

The Irish Times series highlights the State’s ongoing failures in planning and infrastructure

Ireland's changing suburbs
logo
housing graphic
Niamh Towey
Illustration: Paul Scott
Illustration: Paul Scott

Ireland’s suburbs, as charted in this week’s series in The Irish Times, offer a portrait of a country in motion. Suburban living has been part of national life for almost two centuries, although official narratives and depictions have often preferred a rural or inner-city frame. But Ireland is more definitively suburban now than at any point in its history. The shape of suburbia is also shifting, driven by rapid population growth, economic strain and uneven investment.

The most striking feature is the sheer reach of the commuter belt. In the eastern region, it now extends for well over a hundred kilometres. Towns in Meath, Kildare, Wicklow and Wexford have already been transformed. The gravitational pull now reaches even further, into Monaghan, Cavan, Carlow and even Tipperary. Navan, emblematic of this new reality, has absorbed waves of newcomers priced out of areas closer to their workplaces. Meanwhile, working class districts near Dublin’s centre continue to gentrify, while established suburbs experience ongoing additional infill development, mostly in the form of apartment blocks that push density upwards.

It is a complicated picture but some elements stand out. The exodus to surrounding counties is understandable; house prices in cities have placed unbearable pressure on many families, including those originally from the inner suburbs. Relocating offers access to homes that would otherwise be far beyond reach. As the series makes clear, many of these movers are planting roots. Schools, sports clubs and volunteer groups are filling with new arrivals. Communities, though still in formation, are taking shape as people settle and organise.

But the series also highlights the State’s ongoing failures in planning and infrastructure. The ceaseless expansion of the commuter belt flies in the face of Government pledges on climate action. The under-provision of public transport remains stark; overcrowded trains and unreliable buses push more people into cars, adding to congestion and emissions. Within the new suburbs themselves, residents report thinly stretched services and limited civic amenities. Shops and playgrounds only appear years after the first occupants arrive, while medical and childcare facilities struggle to keep pace.

This is not a new story. Suburban developments of the past suffered from similar oversights. What is dispiriting is that the same mistakes are being made despite repeated commitments to best planning practice.

History suggests that residents of these new suburbs will build strong communities regardless; previous generations showed the same resilience. But that does not absolve policymakers. It is clear the current model is unsustainable. It is long past time to align planning and development with the priorities so often professed.