Mother and baby homes inquiry seeks to hear from residents

Commission to focus on 14 homes, with report to be completed by 2018

Patrick Anderson McQuaid, Derek Leinster and Noleen Belton, members of the Bethany Survivors Group, at the burial site of children from the Bethany Home in Harold’s Cross, Dublin.  Photograph: Eric Luke
Patrick Anderson McQuaid, Derek Leinster and Noleen Belton, members of the Bethany Survivors Group, at the burial site of children from the Bethany Home in Harold’s Cross, Dublin. Photograph: Eric Luke

The Mother and Baby Homes Commission of Investigation would like to hear from anyone who was resident in, or who worked, in any of the 14 homes it is investigating, or relevant county homes subject to its inquiries, at any time from 1922 to 1998.

The commission also wants to hear from people who have personal knowledge about the homes, including family members of residents, regular visitors or those who supplied services to them.

The terms include an investigation into high mortality rates recorded in these institutions, the living conditions and social care arrangements in the homes and the exit arrangements made for single women and children on leaving.

The commission has a wide brief, including the power to investigate alleged forced and illegal adoptions from the homes and the relationships between the institutions and children’s homes, orphanages and adoption societies.

READ SOME MORE

It can also investigate postmortem practices including the reporting of deaths, burial arrangements and the transfer of remains to educational institutions for anatomical examinations.

Confidential committee

Work at the commission, which began last February, is “going smoothly”, a spokeswoman said. Its confidential committee was “meeting all the time” to hear stories of people’s experiences in the homes.

The committee’s proceedings are private, as will be the commission’s investigative hearings, though it has powers to hold the latter in public should that be deemed appropriate.

As with the Ryan Commission, which investigated reformatories, industrial schools and orphanages, the Mother and Baby Home Commission’s confidential committee was set up to provide a forum for people who had been resident in the homes or who worked in them and who wish to talk privately about their experiences.

The commission will investigate a representative sample of relevant county homes. This sample has yet to be selected. However records from the county homes “vary hugely” in quality and quantity, the spokeswoman said.

Magdalene laundries

The commission has powers of compellability where necessary. While it will not be investigating Magdalene laundries under its terms of reference, “we do have to identify pathways out of the homes”, she said. Such pathways, in instances, included Magdalene laundries.

Among the 14 mother and baby homes being investigated are the Bethany Home and Ms Carr's in Dublin, which were Protestant-run.

The others are Ard Mhuire at Dunboyne, Co Meath; Belmont in Dublin; Bessboro in Cork; the Bon Secours in Tuam, Co Galway; Denny House in Dublin (originally a Magdalene Home on Lower Leeson Street); Kilrush in Co Clare; Manor House, Castlepollard, Co Westmeath; the Regina Coeli Hostel in Dublin; Sean Ross Abbey in Roscrea, Co Tipperary; St Gerard's in Dublin; St Patrick's in Dublin (originally known as Pelletstown); and the Castle, Newtowncunningham, Co Donegal.

The commission is to report by 2018. It is chaired by Ms Justice Yvonne Murphy.

The commission does not have powers to help people who were adopted from mother and baby homes to trace their identity and birth relatives, nor has it any role in deciding on or awarding redress or compensation.

Its confidential freephone number is 1800-806688 from within the State or 00353-1 -6445088 from outside. It can be contacted via email at info@mbhcoi.ie, or by post.

Patsy McGarry

Patsy McGarry

Patsy McGarry is a contributor to The Irish Times