A bullying case brought by an engineer who accused his former supervisor of repeatedly breaking wind towards him has been dismissed by an Australian appeals court.
The Victoria state Court of Appeal upheld a Supreme Court judge’s ruling that even if engineer David Hingst’s allegations were true, flatulence did not necessarily constitute bullying.
Hingst said he would take his case to the High Court, Australia’s final court of appeal. The 56-year-old is seeking 1.8 million Australian dollars (€980,000) damages from his former Melbourne employer, Construction Engineering.
Hingst told the court that he had moved out of a communal office space to avoid supervisor Greg Short’s flatulence. Hingst alleged that Short would then enter his small, windowless office several times a day and break wind. Hingst “alleged that Short would regularly break wind on him or at him, Short thinking this to be funny”, the two appeal court judges wrote in their ruling.
He would fart behind me and walk away. He would do this five or six times a day
Hingst said he would spray Short with deodorant and called his supervisor “Mr Stinky”.
“He would fart behind me and walk away. He would do this five or six times a day,” Hingst said outside court. Short told the court he did not recall breaking wind in Hingst’s office, “but I may have done it once or twice”.
Hingst also accused Short of being abusive over the phone, using profane language and taunting him.
The appeal judges found Hingst “put the issue of Short’s flatulence to the forefront” of his bullying case, arguing that “flatulence constituted assaults”. The court found that Short did not bully or harass Hingst.
It said Hingst had failed to establish that Construction Engineering had been negligent. Hingst worked for Construction Engineering as a contract administrator from May 2008 until April 2009. He argued he was bullied in the workplace until his job was terminated. Construction Engineering argued his job was terminated because of a downturn in construction work due to the global financial crisis in late 2008.
– Associated Press