A man has lost an appeal against his conviction for murdering 17-year-old Daniel McAnaspie, whose body was found in a farm drain three months after he was stabbed to death.
An orphan who was in the care of the Health Service Executive, the teenager went missing in February 2010.
Richard Dekker first went on trial accused of Mr McAnaspie’s murder in 2013 but was acquitted by direction of the trial judge who said there was a lack of evidence.
Dekker then made legal history when the Supreme Court ruled that under the Criminal Justice Procedure Act 2010 he could face a second trial for the same murder. In 2017 a jury at the Central Criminal Court returned an unanimous verdict convicting Dekker (35), formerly of Whitestown Avenue, Dublin, but now a prisoner in Mountjoy, of murdering Mr McAnaspie.
The jury heard that after Dekker stabbed him to death in Tolka Valley Park, Blanchardstown, on February 26th, 2010, Mr McAnaspie’s body was put in a suitcase and dumped in a drain about 30km away where it was found by a farmer three months later.
Dekker appealed his conviction with his lawyers arguing that the jury at his trial should not have heard answers he gave to gardaí during his final interview at Cabra Garda station. Mr Justice George Birmingham, delivering the ruling of the three-judge court on Wednesday, said the manner in which gardaí conducted the final interview “left much to be desired”. But he found that Dekker’s “self-serving” answers to the questions put by gardaí were admissible.
During the final interview, which took place at about 5am, gardaí told Dekker they were invoking special provisions whereby adverse inferences could be drawn against him if he refused to answer certain questions. Gardaí told him his “credibility will be shot” if he maintained his right to silence. When Dekker asked to speak to his solicitor, gardaí told him they had tried calling but because of the early hour there was no answer. They added: “We are still going to do this. We are entitled.”
Mr Justice Birmingham noted that until that final interview Dekker had refused to answer most questions, other than to occasionally deny any knowledge of what happened to Mr McAnaspie. After the warning from gardaí, he accepted he was there when Mr McAnaspie was murdered but blamed Trevor Noone, who was also being questioned by gardaí at the time. Noone later pleaded guilty to manslaughter in relation to Mr McAnaspie’s death and his plea was accepted.
Dekker’s lawyers argued that gardaí had breached his right to legal representation and that the answers he gave should not have been admitted in trial. However, Mr Justice Birmingham said the real reason Dekker decided to start answering garda questions was not the inference provisions but that gardaí began the interview by reading Noone’s statement in which he placed the entire blame for Mr McAnaspie’s death on Dekker. Mr Justice Birmingham said: “It seems his decision was prompted by a desire to put his version out there.” The judge said although Dekker’s statement was ultimately used by the prosecution to help in convicting him, from Dekker’s perspective at the time he was “coming clean about what had occurred and placing the blame fairly and squarely on the co-suspect”.
Mr Justice Birmingham said the trial judge had not made an error in admitting the interview evidence and he rejected the appeal.
Mr McAnaspie had travelled to Blanchardstown to be with friends but was last seen at about 4am when two of his friends tried to persuade him to come home with them. Mr McAnaspie refused to go, opting to stay with Dekker and Noone. They lured Mr McAnaspie to a secluded area of the park on the pretence that they were going to fight “some lads from Corduff”. But Dekker was carrying one half of a garden shears and used it to stab Mr McAnaspie repeatedly. Dekker and Noone became suspects when gardaí discovered that Mr McAnaspie was last seen in their presence. Both blamed each other for Mr McAnaspie’s death, and both said that he was killed using a garden shears.
Trevor Noone (34), with an address in the Blanchardstown area, was present when Mr McAnaspie was killed and helped to lure him, intending to “give him a few digs”. At a sentencing hearing for Noone in 2017, Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy said Noone knew Dekker was carrying the shears and so put his offence at the upper end for manslaughter and sentenced him to 13 years in prison.